Winning the Culture War, South Park excerpt
By Brian C. Anderson, City Journal, November 3, 2003
|
Many conservatives have attacked South Park for its exuberant vulgarity, calling it "twisted," "vile trash," a "threat to our youth." Such denunciations are misguided. Conservative critics should pay closer attention to what South Park so irreverently jeers at and mocks. As the show’s co-creator, 32-year-old Matt Stone, sums it up: "I hate conservatives, but I really fucking hate liberals." Not for nothing has blogger and former New Republic editor
Andrew Sullivan praised the show for being "the best antidote to PC
culture we have." South Park sharpens the iconoclastic, anti-PC
edge of earlier cartoon shows like The Simpsons and King of
the Hill, and spares no sensitivity. The show’s single black kid is
called Token. One episode, "Cripple Fight," concludes with a slugfest
between the boys’ wheelchair-bound, cerebral-palsy-stricken friend Timmy
and the obnoxious Jimmy, who wants to be South Park’s Number One "handi-capable"
citizen (in his cringe-making PC locution). In another, "Rainforest
Schmainforest," the boys’ school sends them on a field trip to Costa
Rica, led by an activist choir group, "Getting Gay with Kids," which
wants to raise youth awareness about "our vanishing rain forests." Shown
San José, Costa Rica’s capital, the boys are unimpressed: Cartman: [holding his nose] Oh my God, it smells like ass out here!Choir teacher: All right, that does it! Eric Cartman, you respect other cultures this instant.Cartman: I wasn’t saying anything about their culture, I was just saying their citysmells like ass.
The episode concludes with the choir’s new song: Doo doo doo doo doo. Doo doo doo wa. Getting Gay with Kids is here As the disclaimer before each episode states, the show is so offensive "it should not be viewed by anyone." One of the contemporary Left’s most extreme (and, to conservatives,
objectionable) strategies is its effort to draw the mantle of civil
liberties over behavior once deemed criminal, pathological, or immoral,
as a brilliant South Park episode featuring a visit to town by
the North American Man-Boy Love Association—the ultra-radical activist
group advocating gay sex with minors—satirizes: NAMBLA leader: [outside South Park Inn, under arrest]Rights? Does anybody know their rights? You see, I’ve learned something today. Our forefathers came to this country because they believed in an idea. An idea called "freedom." They wanted to live in a place where a group couldn’t be prosecuted for their beliefs. Where a person can live the way he chooses to live. You see us as being perverted because we’re different from you. People are afraid of us, because they don’t understand. And sometimes it’s easier to persecute than to Kyle: Dude. You have sex with children.NAMBLA leader: We are human. Most of us didn’t even choose to be attracted to young boys. We were born that way. We can’t help the way we are, and if you all can’t understand that, well, then, I guess you’ll just have to put us away. Kyle: [slowly, for emphasis] Dude. You have sex with children.Stan: Yeah. You know, we believe in equality for everybody, and tolerance, and all that gay stuff, but dude, fuck you.
Sheila: [Kyle's Mom] Everything is going to be fine, Stan; we’re bringing in Kyle tomorrow to see the Native Americans personally.Stan: Isn’t it possible that these Indians don’t know what they’re talking about?Sharon: [Stan's Mom] You watch your mouth, Stanley. The Native Americans were raped of their land and resources by white people like us.Stan: And that has something to do with their medicines because . . . ?Sharon: Enough, Stanley!
South Park has satirized the sixties counterculture (Cartman has feverish nightmares about hippies, who "want to save the earth, but all they do is smoke pot and smell bad"); anti-big-business zealots (a "Harbucks" coffee chain opens in South Park, to initial resistance but eventual acclaim as everyone—including the local coffee house’s owners—admits its bean beats anything previously on offer in the town); sex ed in school (featuring "the Sexual Harassment Panda," an outrageous classroom mascot); pro-choice extremists (Cartman’s mother decides she wants to abort him, despite the fact that he’s eight years old, relying on the "it’s my body" argument); hate-crime legislation, anti-discrimination lawsuits, gay scout leaders, and much more. Conservatives do not escape the show’s satirical sword—gun-toting rednecks and phony patriots have been among those slashed. But there should be no mistaking the deepest thrust of South Park’s politics. |