Despite a flourishing economy American workers are less confident about
their financial security than they were two years ago. The U.S. has enjoyed
four straight years of economic growth, but most families have lost ground:
In 2005, more than 80% of American workers saw their inflation-adjusted
wages fall for the second year in a row.
While the economy has been growing since 2001, all the benefits of that
growth have gone into corporate profits, says Mark Zandi, chief economist at
Moody’s Economy.com, a
Pennsylvania-based consultant firm: “Corporate profits’ share of the
national income is at a 60-year high—and that has come directly out of wages
and salaries, which are at a record low.” And wages of the top 10% of
earners—people making more than $90,000 a year—have risen much faster than
everyone else’s. The average worker’s pay stayed almost flat at $27,000 from
1990 to 2004, one study finds.
The U.S. added 2 million jobs in 2005—about the same number as in 2004.
Despite the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina, the economy grew 3.6%,
and the unemployment rate fell from 5.1% to 4.9%. But dramatic layoffs
continue. Late last year, GM said it planned to cut 30,000 jobs. In January,
Ford said it would eliminate up to 30,000 jobs too. Since 2000, the Big
Three auto manufacturers have cut, or announced plans to cut, almost 140,000
jobs—a third of their North American payroll.
Most forecasters hope that economic growth will continue this year, albeit
more slowly, since a cooling real-estate market and higher interest rates
are likely to curb consumer spending. Higher energy prices, including home
heating, will hurt spending too. And the burden of consumer debt will be
heavier: This year, major credit-card issuers will increase required minimum
payments from 2.5% to 4% of outstanding balances.
Notwithstanding the low jobless rate, there’s a lot of uneasiness among
workers, notes John Challenger, chief executive of
Challenger, Gray &
Christmas, a Chicago-based outplacement firm. “Many people have been
falling behind, especially in the middle class,” he says. In 2005, for the
first time since the Great Depression, Americans borrowed more than they
earned. “Wages haven’t kept up with inflation, and many employers have
pushed the cost of health care back to employees in the form of higher
premiums and co-pays,” notes Challenger. “Added to that, there’s the higher
cost of driving to and from work and heating a home.”
That uneasiness is reflected in PARADE’s annual survey and other polls. “The
experts tell the nation that the economy is strong, but the fact is the
people you talk to—real people—are struggling,” says Donnie Betts, 53, a
documentary filmmaker from Aurora, Colo., who earned $53,000 last year.
Teresa L. Harrison, 46, an accounting technician from Lake Panasoffkee,
Fla., who made $32,200, tells us: “My income will probably increase slightly
this year, but I doubt the increase will cover the higher cost of insurance
and gas.” Other respondents agree: “Salaries just don’t seem to be keeping
up with the average person’s cost to live,” says James Norton, 41, of
Baltimore, who earned $37,600 as a police records supervisor. Adds Paula
Goldie, 51, of Troutdale, Ore., who made $40,600 as a municipal court clerk:
“I feel like I’m treading water, hoping not to get swamped.”
The median weekly salary in 2005 was $659 (half of all workers earned more,
half earned less). After inflation, that’s 1.9% less than in 2004. Average
hourly pay for all production and nonsupervisory workers was $16.11—a 0.7%
decline when adjusted for inflation. Workers’ retirement and health-care
benefits also are shrinking—and not only in troubled industries. Financially
healthy companies are freezing their pension plans to exclude new hires
and/or younger employees—a trend that’s expected to continue. In a frozen
plan, workers stop accruing benefits. This also hurts longtime workers,
because they will retire with much less than they expected: Up to 50% of a
pension is earned in the last five years on the job.
Health-insurance premiums rose 9.2% in 2005, more than 21⁄2 times the
inflation rate. Some firms are saving money by switching to “limited-benefit
plans,” which may not cover the cost of hospital care or serious illnesses.
Others no longer offer health benefits: Only 60% of businesses now provide
them, down from 69% in 2000. Since 2000, the premiums employers pay to cover
workers have gone up 73%. The average cost of family coverage last year was
$10,880. Companies are passing a bigger share of that expense to their
employees. The average worker paid $2,713 in premiums in 2005. Some
employees must choose between health benefits and higher wages. For example,
Sue Greer-Pitt, 55, an associate community college professor from Jackhorn,
Ky., earned $42,500 and got a 4% raise last year—but her raise was
conditional on accepting a health policy that costs her more and covers
less.
Anger at the disparity between record corporate profits and shrinking
workers’ wages and benefits is a driving force behind “living wage laws,” in
which states, municipalities and cities set their minimum wages higher than
the $5.15 federal minimum wage, which hasn’t been increased since 1997.
The economy has grown while real wages have fallen because consumers keep
spending—thanks to soaring real-estate values and low-interest loans. In
2005 alone, Americans borrowed an estimated $887 billion from their homes
through mortgage refinancing and equity loans. The housing boom also has
created 1.1 million jobs in fields like real-estate brokerage, mortgage
lending, construction and the manufacture and sale of home products. Indeed,
our survey respondents in home sales jobs reported the most dramatic 2005
wage gains. Ray Singhal, 62, a Minneapolis-area real-estate agent, saw his
compensation jump 50% last year, to $600,000. And in Redmond, Wash.,
Michelle Traina, 37, saw her earnings jump from $44,000 to $96,000 after she
was promoted from home sales representative to home sales manager.
But the housing market started to lose steam by the end of 2005. This year,
economic growth is likely to depend on corporate spending. Businesses
haven’t made substantial capital investments since the 1990s, but they are
flush with cash, and many economists predict they’ll start spending this
year. Mark Zandi of Moody’s Economy.com says it’s already happening:
“Businesses are investing aggressively in machine tools, aircraft and
construction equipment. If that continues, it should be a reasonably good
year for job growth.”
The biggest growth will be in financial services, technology, health care
and energy, John Challenger says. He predicts high demand for accountants,
petroleum engineers, physical therapists, pharmacists, computer specialists,
and international sales and marketing managers. Every problem creates new
job opportunities: Fear of identity theft has opened up jobs in data
security. And heightened national security creates jobs in defense-related
fields, from aerospace to software development, as well as in law
enforcement. Many police departments are offering higher pay, housing
allowances and, in some cases, signing bonuses for bilingual skills.
Education is vital to getting a good job. On average, full-time workers with
a high school diploma earn $585 a week; those with a college degree earn
$1,029. Men with advanced degrees make $2,887 or more; women make $1,997 or
more. But for most families, getting a college degree requires significant
sacrifices. Since 1990, while median family income has risen 5.8%, the cost
of a bachelor’s degree jumped 63% at public colleges and 47% at private
colleges.
Workers need perseverance, stamina, flexibility and patience to succeed in
this difficult environment. Among PARADE’s survey respondents this year, two
young women seem to exemplify those qualities:
Betty Chu, 29, earned $38,000 as a program coordinator at Harvard Business
School—15% less than she made in 2004 as an elementary schoolteacher. “I was
willing to take the pay cut to work at Harvard because of the opportunities
for advancement,” she says. “I’ve taken on a second job to supplement my
income, and I’m finding more and more ways to cut everyday costs.”
Latoya Milana, 26, made $13,000 working full-time as a support professional
in a group home for the handicapped. She’s also a full-time nursing student.
In 2004, she left a $25,000 job as an accounts-receivable specialist in
medical billing to continue her education. “Next year, I’ll make much more
money doing a job I love,” she says. “But money isn’t everything. I’d rather
make less at a job I love than more at a job I have a hard time waking up
for.”
2005 Median Weekly Wages
Petroleum engineers: $1,923
Actuaries: $1,639
Lawyers: $1,609
Economists: $1,569
Chiropractors: $1,531
Aerospace engineers: $1,362
Medical and health-service managers:
$1,089
Meeting and convention planners: $912
Loan counselors and officers: $861
Elementary schoolteachers: $826
Funeral directors: $768
Social workers: $700
Pest-control workers: $508
Animal trainers: $482
Actors: $481
Child-care workers: $332
Dishwashers: $296
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Hot Jobs In 2006 and Beyond:
International advertising & promotions
managers: $33,760 to $145,000+
Pharmacists: $62,780 to $112,530
Personal financial planners:$31,340
to $108,740
Loan officers: $24,090 to $102,830
Physical therapists: $42,910 to
$89,830
Nurses: $24,910 to $77,170
Electricians: $25,730 to $70,200
Source for average annual range of
salaries: Challenger, Gray & Christmas, with data provided by the Bureau of
Labor Statistics.