Honors 110 -- Fall, 2009

“History’s Mysteries”

 

The Honors Program . The Queens Honors Program provides qualified students with an opportunity to work at an advanced level on topics of interest in seminars and in individually guided studies with Queens faculty leading, ultimately, to an Honors Thesis which you write under the direction of a faculty member who is an expert in the area of your topic. The work in honors courses is designed to challenge gifted students and help them improve their critical thinking skills, their research methods, and their ability to argue a claim persuasively.  For many this good preparation for further study at the graduate level, and for all it is intended to provide an enriching experience that will challenge your intellect and ignite your imagination.

 

 Honors 110: History’s Mysteries. The freshman honors course is designed to introduce first year students to the honors program and honors work.  In this course you will have an opportunity to 1) meet and work with other gifted and motivated students, and 2) sharpen your analytical and research skills by investigating a variety of topics that have teased the human mind for centuries. This semester the topic is History’s Mysteries in which we will examine a range of unexplained phenomena like the Bermuda Triangle, Stonehenge, the lost city of Atlantis, and Crop Circles; questionable existences like UFO’s, the Loch Ness Monster, and Big Foot; legends with basis in historical fact like King Arthur and the Trojan War; conspiracy theories like Area 51 and the Apollo Moon Landing; and debated identities like Jack the Ripper and the authorship of Shakespeare’s plays.

 

By the end of the semester, students should be able to:

·        Understand the difference between causation and correlation

·        Understand the different types of explanation possible for any given event

·        Evaluate extraordinary claims and anecdotal evidence

·        Identify fallacies and construct logical arguments

·        Recognize archetypes in story patterns and the “kernel” of truth in fantastic legends

 

Instructors:        Dr. Reed Perkins                                           Dr. Richard Goode

                         Walker 115A, MW 1:30-4:00                       McEwen 210, MWF 11-12

                         Phone: 704-337-2393                                   Phone: 704-337-2206
                         e-mail: perkinsr@queens.edu                          e-mail: gooder@queens.edu


There will also be guest instructors at times who will share their investigations into history’s mysteries.

 

Meeting Times: The class will meet from 8:30 to 11:00 on Thursday morning in Dana 102.  We may on some occasions meet in other locations or take a field trip.

 

Texts: There are no texts, per se, for the class.  There will be a Reader with articles and examples of several History's Mysteries for you to read.  Other materials will be in the form of hand-outs and on-line reading assignments.  See the on-line syllabus @ http://campus.queens.edu/depts/english/honors%20program%20page.htm

 Requirements:

Exercises and homework assignments...........................15%

Participation.................................................................15%

Mid-Term Exam ..........................................................30%

Research Project.                      Individual paper.......... 25%
            Web Sites for Projects                 Group presentation.......15%

 

Grading:     

A       93 – 100      4.0       Excellent
A-      90 – 92        3.7  
B+      87 – 89        3.5
B        83 – 86        3.0       Very Good
B-       80 – 82        2.7

 C+     77 – 79         2.5
 C       73 – 76         2.0       Satisfactory
 C-      70 – 72         1.7
  D+     65 – 69        1.5
 D        60 – 64        1.0       Poor
 F     Below 6 0       0.0       Unsatisfactory

Daily Readings:

 

1. The Importance of Rational Inquiry

Aug 28

Introductions  

In-class Reading: “Book Excerpt: Assault on Reason,” Time Magazine. May 16, 2007
   Weekly World News    Tabloids & Truthiness
                           A Skeptic Challenges Colbert

        

Sep 4

Reasoned Thought
Read: "The Search for Truth"    
          "The Scientific Method"                      

           “Truthiness” and “Wiki wars rage in political arena”  NPR   Article (Corporate Edits)
             Tabloids & Truthiness

          “Conservapedia.com”  Wikipedia v. Conservapedia

          “If scientific theories keep changing, where’s the Truth?”
           Are we devaluing Science?  The Reliability of Wikipedia (listen to the report)

Sep 11
Note the date!

Reality vs. Fiction vs. The “in between”

Read: “Debunking the 9/11 Myths”             Video: Bombs in the Buildings  Creepy Facts

          “Why the 9/11 Conspiracy Theories Won’t Go Away”

           "9/11 Conspiracy Theories” 9/11 Conspiracy Theory

Watch: McCain and Obama Election Commercials (Choose several ads from each candidate and analyze their effectiveness.  Consider how they work: what is said or written? what are the facts? how are visuals used? to what effect?  Do the ads "speak the truth to us" or "feel the truth at us"?
Does the truth suffer in these ads?  Do negative ads actually reveal important things about the other candidate?
Look at these sites FOR SURE!!  Politifact.com   and  Factcheck.org

Here are some more 2008 political ads up to date.
Ads to watch: Be sure to look at these.   Sex Ed ad

 

 

  1. The “How To” Guide for Rational Inquiry

Sep 18

Observation
Read: "Observation and Evidence"

          “Ockham’s Razor”
          “Brown Mountain Lights”
Read:  Crop Circle Research  Theories

View:  UFO Sightings                     

Sep 25

Causation vs. Correlation

Read:  "Causation v. Correlation"

           “Diet Sodas Linked to Heart Disease”

           “Obesity is ‘Socially Contagious’”
           “Full Moon Causes Accidents” & “Why Friday the 13th is Unlucky”

Review: “How to  Lie and Cheat with Statistics
View: The DeColbert Code    Oscar Winners 2006
          The Skeptic   A Skeptic Challenges Colbert

Oct 2

Explanations: The how, what, and why
 Easter Island: Faces of Mystery
 Delphic Oracle: Background & History  Prophetic Gases?  More Gas  Last Word from Scientific American
       Stonehenge: Healing Place      Stonehenge: Holy Grail Vortex  
       Is Testosterone Responsible for the Financial Crisis?

Oct 9

Evaluating Extraordinary Claims

Read: "Extraordinary Claims"

            “Astrological Charts

            Daniel Caton on Astrology

          "Extraordinary Claims: Interview with Carl Sagan"
View: The Amazing Randi with Uri Geller and James Hydrick on YouTube
Uban legends, etc.: Snopes.com

Oct 16       Fall Break

Oct 23

Arguments, Fallacies, and Pipedreams

Read: "Fallacies in the Name of Science"     Non Sequitur

 

Oct 30

1. Mid Term Examination

2. Faculty Presentation    Read: Stonehenge

Nov 6

Service Learning Day   Photos

 

  1. Student Presentations

Nov 13

Student Presentations
     Read about: Mayans         Jack the Ripper      Bermuda Triangle   Video

Nov 20

Student Presentations

      Read About: The Holy Grail  and Video
      Read: Noah's Ark

Nov 27

Thanksgiving

Dec 4           

 Open Discussion

   

 

 Photos

Honor Code

Academic dishonesty (lying, cheating, plagiarism) is a violation of the Honor Code.  Academic Dishonesty may take many forms including, but not limited to, lying to gain an academic advantage; falsification of data, or failure to give credit to sources. Plagiarism is the representing of another’s work as your own.  In this class you must accurately cite and properly document all sources you have used on your term paper.  Use the skills you learned in ENG 110-120. Cheating is defined as using trickery, deceit, or fraud to gain an unfair advantage. 

 

I trust you, and do not assume for a moment that anyone will violate the Honor Code.  I will not hover over you during exams but will leave you on your honor.  It is your honor code and you must make it work by policing yourselves. Anyone who breaks the code in your presence is violating your trust and dishonoring your community.

 

In order to affirm your support of the Honor Code, you are asked to pledge all the work you submit in this class.  This can be done by affixing and signing a simple statement on quizzes, exams, and papers you turn in: “I pledge that I have neither given nor received aid on this quiz/exam/paper.”  Then sign it.
 

Disabilities

 

If you are a student with a verified disability and you require accommodations, please provide me with the necessary memorandum that was given to you by Student Disabilty Services.

Contact: Sandy Rogelberg, MA, LPC, NCC

Phone: 704-337-2508

Email: rogelbes@queens.edu

 

Dumb Test http://www.quizrocket.com/dumb-test/7?gatherer_id=100437&utm_source=100437&utm_medium=Pop&utm_campaign=Dumb7